A fresh handmade Schmucker’s Pie will always excede your expectations. Stop in and enjoy a piece or take a whole one home to share. They are special for all occasions. Ordering your pies in advance is always encouraged. However, when you need it TODAY, not tomorrow, whole “Pies Availabe Daily” are able to be purchased on a first come first serve basis. Whole “Specialty Pies” are availble only by order, except when offered as the “Pie of the Week”. Call to learn this week’s offering.
To Order Call: 419.787.9572. Please note that we cannot accept pie orders via email.
Pies Available Daily |
Specialty Pies |
| Apple | Almond Joy |
| Banana | ANDE’s Mint Delight |
| Blueberry | Apple-Raisin-Walnut |
| Scutterbotch | Black Bottom |
| Caramel-Apple-Walnut | Black Forest |
| Cherry | Blueberry Crumb |
| Cherry Berry | Burst O’ Berry |
| Cherry Crumb | Butterfinger |
| Chocolate Cream | Candy Apple |
| Chocolate Peanut Butter | Chocolate Raspberry Cream |
| Custard | Coconut Custard |
| Dutch Apple | French Peach |
| Keylime | Lemon Crunch |
| Lemon Meringue | Mounds |
| Mince * | Nestle Crunch |
| Peach | OH-IO Buckeye Pie |
| Pecan | OREO |
| Pumpkin * | Oatmeal |
| Raisin | Pineapple Cream |
| Rhubarb | Pumpkin Apple Streusel |
| Strawberry Rhubarb * | Raspberry Cream |
| Fresh Strawberry * | ScutterBotch Mousse |
| Vanilla Peanut Butter | Snicker’s |
| Sugar Free Pies | Strawberry / Rhubarb |
| Fresh Strawberry Banana * | |
| * Seasonal (order 48 hours in advance) | Sweet Potato Streusel * |
| Triple Chocolate Indulgence | |
| Cheesecakes Available | |
| Plain | Blueberry |
| Turtle | Peanut Butter |
| Cherry | Strawberry |