Never been to Schmucker’s? Take a look around.

  • Pies Available Daily

    We're now accepting Christmas pie orders! A limited number of orders will be taken so order yours today.

    Choose your favorites from this list:

    Pumpkin Caramel Apple Walnut Dutch Apple
    Cherry Crumb Peach Crumb Blueberry Crumb
    Peppermint Stick Brownie Pecan Cheesecake
    Blueberry Cheesecake Cherry Cheesecake Strawberry Cheesecake
    Turtle Cheesecake Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb Custard
    Chocolate Peanut Butter Vanilla Peanut Butter Oreo Cookie
    Banana Chocolate Cream Coconut
    Apple
    (no sugar added)    		 Cherry
    (no sugar added)

    No variations or changes to these pie options.
    The last day to order is December 20th.


    A fresh handmade Schmucker's Pie will always exceed your expectations. Stop in and enjoy a piece or take a whole pie home to share. They are special for all occasions. Ordering your pies in advance is always encouraged. However, when you need it TODAY, not tomorrow, whole pies on the Pies Available Daily list can be purchased on a first-come, first-served basis. Whole Specialty Pies are available only by order, except when offered as the Pie of the Week.
    Call to learn this week's offering.

    To order, call: 419.535.9116.
    • Coconut Cream
    • Vanilla Peanut Butter
    • Fresh Strawberry*
    • Rhubarb
    • Pumpkin*
    • Pecan
    • Peach
    • Mince*
    • Key Lime*
      A delightful dance of sweet and tart that's sure to arouse the taste buds!
    • Dutch Apple
      Grandma Nola's original recipe. À la mode is the way to go!
    • Custard
    • Chocolate Peanut Butter
    • Chocolate Cream
    • Cherry Crumb
    • Cherry†
    • Caramel-Apple-Walnut
    • Scutterbotch
    • Blueberry†
    • Banana
    • Apple†
    • Strawberry Rhubarb*
    • † Available with no sugar added
      Available whole with pre order
    • * Seasonal

  • Specialty Pies

    • Peppermint Stick Brownie
    • Peach Crumb
    • Chocola-Scotch
    • Oreo Cookie
    • Raspberry Cream
    • Pumpkin Apple Streusel
    • OH-IO Buckeye
    • Chocolate Raspberry Cream
    • Butterfinger
    • Blueberry Crumb
    • Black Bottom
      A bottom layer of delightful fudge with chocolate & vanilla homemade pudding topped with whipped cream drizzled with fudge.
    • Andes Mint Delight

  • Cheesecakes Available

    • Strawberry
      Our homemade smooth and creamy cheesecake topped with a layer of fresh strawberries and homemade glaze.
    • Peanut Butter
    • Blueberry
    • Cherry
    • Turtle
    • Plain
?>